Jump to content

Hornby R2946 4-VEP


Metadyneman
 Share

Recommended Posts

Well I'll be interested to see how it looks and performs although it's doubtful that I'll be in the market for one with so many other models on the horizon. Being a 'northerner' I'm not familiar at all with the southern electrics and although I find them appealing (I did get 3 versions of the Bachmann 4CEPs) I'm saving myself for more familiar products.

Traction tyres don't sound good for outdoor use. Why on earth would Hornby feel the need for traction tyres on a short 4 car unit?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

From what I have read elsewhere so far it would seem Hornby have used their self contained motor bogie similar to that used in the 156. This motor bogie is light in construction and without traction tyres would not pull the skin off a rice pudding. Mine has been dispatched and is on it's way as we speak so I'll be giving it the once over during the weekend and will hopefully draw up some kind of a review by Sunday.

I agree though, traction tyres are not good on outdoor lines and are next to useless in dampened conditions.. I suppose it has to be said that the majority of models are not designed for outdoor use, but it would have been nicer if Hornby had used a similar mechanism to the one Bachmann have used in their CEP and EPB. That in my opinion is an outstanding motor and mechanism for both fast and slow running without wheelslip.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've just been reading the Hornby 4-VEP review in this months British Railway Modelling. It looks a nice model and receives a positive response barring a few minor niggles.

Regarding the performance, the review states "The pair of traction tyres fitted to the drive bogie further enhances traction. Performance was, as expected, smooth and controllable"

A positive note for me was the inclusion of "...simple body clips securing the MBSO body to its floor... ...appreciated when it comes to fitting a decoder". You'll have to let us know just how easy that really is!

The through electrical connections are also most welcome for this kind of unit.

Looking forward to seeing it in action soon - perhaps some photos?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Being in the fortuitous position of having two computers, I am at this very moment saving a very hastily made video filmed this morning on the garden line. It depicts the VEP in tandem with the all blue modelzone CEP and later in a 12 car consist of two CEPs and a VEP! Here are one or two of my own observations. Firstly, the train looks like a 4-VEP! That is probably the most important feature of any prototypical model. There are shortcomings but they are not terminal to anyone wanting to improve it.

OK so the bad bits what are they? I'll start with the horns, they are way too small as are the roof ventilators, the front profile Isn't quite right and the bright full yellow ends accentuate that. I will include traction tyres as a bad point but in essence it's only on one axle so it isn't too bad. The biggest boo,boo in my book is the 1st class corridor compartment partition in the driving Trailer Composite Lavatory Coach (the southern have always loved their toilets in train classification, the best being the 4-LAV!). It is one solid "wall" and you cannot see through the coach from the corridor side to the compartment side. That has to be something Hornby needs to change in the model and I hope they do in subsequent versions.

Now for the good points, The motor bogie is a delight to look at and captures the look of the real thing perfectly. Underframe detail is also superb. The couplings between cars are good if a little scary to look at. They incorporate a 4 pin plug & socket system. It's a tad fiddly to couple them but not as fiddly as the Bachmann 4-CEP. You just have to be gentle and ensure the 4 pins line up with the 4 corresponding holes in the socket. The motor is powerful and very fast too, it is a faster unit than the 4-CEP. Because of this, it will be difficult if not impossible to consist the Hornby VEP with the Bachmann CEP on analogue DC.(On DCC it's fairly easy to adjust the top speed by tweaking CV5 (I used a Bachmann 36-553 decoder) down to about 18, that just about matches the top speed of the 4-CEP but i won't bore you with DCC balls!) The interior lighting is very good indeed and even better is the fact that the headcode lighting changes in accordance with the direction of travel. Hornby include stickers to go over the top of the headcode window and the two white squares are particularly effective and show red in reverse and white (yellow LED) in forward position. Fitting a decoder is as easy as described in the model railway press but it is important to take care with the fly leads between the body & chassis the motor coach when separating one from the other. The paint finish is very good and the double arrow and numbering is well executed. The silver frames round the windows are also very good but it's slightly disappointing that the top sliding vents are only depicted by a printed silver line on the glazing, these were quite prominent on the real units even after they had been bolted shut in the mid 80s and if you look down the train it looks too flush sided as a result. My example is an extremely smooth runner however and despite the scepticism before it's release, I think Hornby have scored a hit with this train.

To summarise, There are improvements Hornby could do to this unit most notably and perhaps easily, the solid corridor "wall" and slightly larger horns, but I think early criticism of this unit before it's release was a little premature and it will be a popular model. Here's the video

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Excellent review - really top notch - I'm almost tempted to go out and buy one now!

The video too is excellent and fully up to the standard I have come to expect from the Bambrough Line. Love the 12 car set and it's good to see your layout from different angles, some of which make it look so much bigger than it actually is. Thanks for posting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...